Disputes

Disputes

Homebuyer/Homeseller Dispute Resolution

Optional Agreement: The Residential Real Property Arbitration program is a voluntary, optional means of dispute resolution on issues relating to disclosure of material facts pertaining to the property. The system, which serves as an alternative to litigation, is endorsed by the Minnesota REALTORS® and administered by the National Center for Dispute Settlement ("NCDS"). This option should be presented to the parties at or about the time that a listing agreement, a buyer representation agreement, or the purchase agreement is signed. The agreement to arbitrate these disputes is enforceable only if all buyers, sellers, and licensees representing or assisting the buyers and sellers consent by signing the Arbitration Agreement form. (This is because any of those parties or brokers/agents could be named as parties in arbitration.) By agreeing to arbitrate such disputes, the parties give up the right to resolve those issues in court. The Arbitration Disclosure and Agreement is a separate form, not an addendum to the purchase agreement, and failure to sign that form has no effect on the purchase agreement.

Arbitration or Court: Brokers/Agents should review the Rules under which the Arbitration program is administered (available from NCDS). Arbitration is often a quicker, cheaper, and simpler means of resolving disputes for buyers and sellers. Parties should be aware, however, of a number of significant differences between use of the arbitration and litigation systems to resolve a dispute, including the following:

  • The initial cost of filing a claim is higher for arbitration than for filing a lawsuit.
  • The time deadline for filing an arbitration claim is more limited than in litigation.
  • The probable length of time from filing a claim until an award or decision is made is often much shorter in arbitration than when litigating a dispute.
  • The site of the arbitration hearing is usually at the subject property.
  • Appeal and pre-hearing discovery rights in arbitration are very limited.

Brokers/Agents can make available to customers and clients copies of the Arbitration FAQ as well as the NCDS Rules and fee schedule to assist in making the decision whether to consent to arbitration for resolution of disputes over property condition.

The arbitration option should be presented to buyers and sellers at or about the time the purchase agreement is prepared. Copies of the NCDS Rules governing the program can be made available to the parties at or before that time. The MN REALTORS® standardized purchase agreement contains signature lines for the parties' acknowledgment of receipt of the Arbitration Disclosure and Residential Real Property Arbitration Agreement form. Agents should become familiar with the NCDS system, and be aware of whether their office has a policy relating to arbitration.

Demand for Arbitration: To file a demand for Arbitration, contact NCDS to request a Demand for Arbitration or Submission Form as well as Rules the Residential Real Property Arbitration and the fee schedule at 866.727.8119, or you can download this information from the NCDS website at www.ncdsusa.org.

Print out the MN REALTORS®/NCDS brochure "A Guide to Residential Arbitration"

 

Buyer/Seller Mediation Services

The Minnesota REALTORS® has created a program that provides mediation services to interested parties as an alternative to arbitration and litigation. In today's litigious society, increasing numbers of people are finding that mediation is a more satisfying process than arbitration or litigation in the resolution of disputes.

What is Mediation? Mediation is a process in which the parties, with the assistance of a qualified neutral Mediation Officer, attempt to resolve their dispute based on the factual information, without focusing on who is right and who is wrong or what is equitable (two legal concepts). Instead, the parties focus on what each is willing to do to put the dispute behind them.

During the mediation conference, the parties tend to concentrate on their highest priorities and move towards a compromise on lower priority issues. The Mediation Officer will attempt to create and maintain an atmosphere or communication between the parties while facilitating their negotiation.

Initiating a Claim: Mediation is a viable alternative to litigation or formal arbitration. Consider resolving your disputes by electing to use our mediation services. To initiate the process, please download MN REALTORS'® "Mediation Rules and Guidelines" and "Request to Mediate Form."